Book Report: HCP Students Rank Their Favorite and Least Favorite Assigned Novels
Across four years of high school, Harding Charter Prep students work through a wide range of novels and plays. Naturally, some titles land far better than others. The Marionette asked students which assigned books they loved most and which ones they would happily never open again.

Top Three Favorites
Third Place: A Raisin in the Sun
Lorraine Hansberry's play, assigned as summer reading for AP Literature seniors, earned three votes and settled comfortably in the middle of the rankings. Even though it tackles weighty themes like segregation and the drive to build a better life, it still drew some mixed feelings. "I liked it, but the ending frustrated me," senior Jayla Wilson said.
Second Place: The Catcher in the Rye
J.D. Salinger's novel collected four positive votes. Readers described it as an enjoyable, looser read, though it had its detractors too. "I thought the main character was lame," senior Sebastian Dover said.
First Place: Fahrenheit 451
Ray Bradbury's dystopian classic won by a wide margin. Read during freshman year, it sparked lively classroom discussion and was called thought-provoking and "not boring." "It was just cool to read, interesting," senior Tanner Litle said.
Explore the books mentioned: A Raisin in the Sun, The Catcher in the Rye, and Fahrenheit 451.
Bottom Three Least Favorites
Third Place: The Odyssey
Homer's ancient epic landed third among the least-liked titles, though it still pulled in a fair number of positive votes. "[It] was something different than what I was expecting," senior Korbin Nida said. Still, five students named it their least favorite, pointing to the heavy workload and the difficulty of following the poem. "I had no idea what was going on that whole time," senior Divine Visbal said. Learn more about The Odyssey.
Second Place: A Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy
Douglas Adams' novel drew few votes, and every one of them was negative. Senior Caleb Caldwell called it "just kind of dumb," while Dover summed up how forgettable it felt: "Wasn't that the book where they destroyed the earth to make way for a space highway or something?" Few students actually read it, since it was one of three options for AP Literature summer reading.
First Place: Candide
Voltaire's 1759 satire, read during sophomore year, failed to connect with today's students. "The first half was just rape and murder," junior Adam Peters said. "Then even the ending didn't seem to make much sense either." When senior Kamryn Downs asked during a discussion, "Did anyone like that book?" the answer was no. Not a single favorite-book vote went to Candide, making it the clear pick for least-liked assigned reading. Read more about Candide by Voltaire.
Share Your Take
Have a favorite or least favorite assigned novel you want to talk about? Email us at [email protected] and tell us what you think.
Photo credit: Sharon McCutcheon (Pexels)
About the Reporter

Lucas Evans is a senior at Harding Charter Prep who enjoys biking, swimming, and photography. He joined online news to sharpen his journalism skills. Read more from Lucas Evans.
Reader Poll
Do you prefer winter or summer? Cast your vote and see what other readers think.

View Results Polls Archive
Recent Comments
More Stories

- Teardown
- 1989 never goes out of 'Style'
- The Summer I Turned Pretty: Book or Movie?
- Rapper seems to feel 'Away From Home' with new song
- It's the great pumpkin spice latte, Charlie Brown!
- Homeword bound to Kharak
- Jazzy talent night coming soon
- A love-hate relationship with 'Fall Guys'
- 'Disconnected' at the 5 Seconds of Summer show
- Guards! Guards! By Terry Pratchett: a review
Support Student Journalism
Your donation helps The Marionette's student journalists cover school, national, and international news while building skills for future careers. Go Eagles!
Share This Story
Connect With The Marionette
Site Links
